Opinion
Op-ed: Property rights
Published
13 years agoon
By John Vincent
The corporate opposition to IR 125, the citizens referendum to repeal
the new HB 198 eminent domain law, continues to claim that ‘the new
law is the same as the old law.’ Their claim is a textbook example of
how to mislead by omission and the careful choice of words. As Paul
Harvey use to say, here’s “the rest of the story.”
HB 198 did, in fact, significantly change Montana eminent domain law
because it wrote specific language into statute (Montana’s official
laws as passed by the legislature) that had never been in statute
before. It created a “one stop shopping” mechanism by which private
individuals and corporations can all too easily secure the right of
eminent domain for private, for-profit projects.
Under the new HB 198 law, eminent domain and condemnation rights are
“automatically” granted to a corporate applicant upon the issuance of
a certificate of compliance from the Department of Environmental
Quality (DEQ) under the Major Facility Siting Act (MFSA) This
certificate is all that’s necessary for a corporation to obtain the
right of eminent domain and the right to condemn private property.
“One Stop Shopping.”
Why is this a problem? It’s a problem for three reasons:
First, because it establishes a corporations right of eminent domain
for a private project upon the approval of DEQ, instead of having to
obtain those rights separately under another Montana statute. HB 198
supporters also cling to what’s called the Fondren decision, in which
they claim the court conferred eminent domain rights on an applicant
under MFSA. Clearly the corporate supporters of HB 198 had so little
confidence in their legal positions, and such a compelling interest in
obtaining eminent domain and condemnation rights as quickly and easily
as possible, that they went to a compliant legislature to create a new
“one stop shopping” law instead of making their case in court.
Second, it’ a problem because MFSA is essentially a “toothless tiger.”
The legislature has torn it apart and weakened it session after
session for years. HB 198 supporters like to say that a “public need”
must be established under MFSA for a corporation to obtain eminent
domain for a private, for-profit project. Sounds good but it’s really
no obstacle at all, primarily because the public need criteria in
MFSA are so broad, general and generic that it would be difficult,
maybe even impossible, NOT to find a public need.
In addition, the fact that most new transmission lines really aren’t
“public need” lines but “market lines,” isn’t addressed in MFSA.
Because of deregulation, transmission lines are now built first and
foremost to market and sell more electricity, (not meet an objectively
established “public need” within a regulated service area).
Finally, politics. In practice, the DEQ siting process for major
projects isn’t a neutral, objective fact finding exercise at all.
It’s, at base, a political process in which data is collected and
selected to support the findings needed to issue a certificate of
compliance.
And how’s that? When a governor, any governor of either party, picks
up the phone and tells his/her DEQ director, “I want this project,”
guess what? Game Over. Done Deal. The “public need,” the project, the
certificate of compliance and the right of eminent domain to condemn
private property are all handed to a private corporation, virtually on
a silver platter.
The HB 198 eminent domain law is a huge, misguided change, and blaming
the supporters of IR 125 for misrepresenting it has gone on long
enough. This I know; “Blame is always never enough. It just keeps you
in the game, ‘till you’ve only got yourself left to bluff.”
John Vincent is a Montana Public Service Commissioner and former two
term Speaker of the Montana House of Representatives.
Megan Paulson is the Co-Founder and Chief Operating Officer of Outlaw Partners.
Upcoming Events
april, 2024
Event Type :
All
All
Arts
Education
Music
Other
Sports
Event Details
Children turning 5 on or before 9/10/2024:
more
Event Details
Children turning 5 on or before
9/10/2024: Kindergarten
enrollment for the 2024-2025 school year can be completed by following the
registration process now.
Children
born on or after September 11, 2019: 4K enrollment is now open for
families that have a 4-year-old they would like to enroll in our program for
the 2023-2024 school year. Please complete the 4K Interest Form to
express your interest. Completing this form does not guarantee enrollment into
the 4K program. Enrollment is capped at twenty 4-year-olds currently
residing within Big Sky School District boundary full time and will be
determined by birth date in calendar order of those born on or after September
11, 2018. Interest form closes on May 30th.
Enrollment now is critical for fall preparations. Thank you!
Time
February 26 (Monday) - April 21 (Sunday)
Event Details
Saturday, March 23rd 6:00-8:00pm We will combine the heart-opening powers of cacao with the transcendental powers of breathwork and sound. Together, these practices will give us the opportunity for a deep
more
Event Details
Saturday, March 23rd 6:00-8:00pm
Time
March 23 (Saturday) 6:00 pm - April 23 (Tuesday) 8:00 pm
Location
Santosha Wellness Center
169 Snowy Mountain Circle
Event Details
We all are familiar with using a limited palette, but do you use one? Do you know how to use a
more
Event Details
We all are familiar with using a limited palette, but do you use one? Do you know how to use a limited palette to create different color combinations? Are you tired of carrying around 15-20 different tubes when you paint plein air? Have you ever wanted to create a certain “mood” in a painting but failed? Do you create a lot of mud? Do you struggle to achieve color harmony? All these problems are addressed in John’s workbook in clear and concise language!
Based on the bestselling “Limited Palatte, Unlimited Color” workbook written by John Pototschnik, the workshop is run by Maggie Shane and Annie McCoy, accomplished landscape (acrylic) and plein air (oil) artists,exhibitors at the Big Sky Artists’ Studio & Gallery and members of the Big Sky Artists Collective.
Each student will receive a copy of “Limited Palette, Unlimited Color” to keep and take home to continue your limited palette journey. We will show you how to use the color wheel and mix your own clean mixtures to successfully create a mood for your paintings.
Each day, we will create a different limited palette color chart and paint a version of a simple landscape using John’s directives. You will then be able to go home and paint more schemes using the book for guidance.
Workshop is open to painters (oil or acrylic) of any level although students must have some basic knowledge of the medium he or she uses. Students will be provided the book ($92 value), color wheel, value scale and canvas papers to complete the daily exercises.
Sundays, April 14, 21 and 28, 2024
Noon until 6PM.
$170.
Time
14 (Sunday) 12:00 pm - 28 (Sunday) 6:00 pm
Event Details
Come join us at Cowboy Coffee as we celebrate a fun night of drinks, games, and meeting others within the community. This event is from 6-8 and all are welcome
Event Details
Come join us at Cowboy Coffee as we celebrate a fun night of drinks, games, and meeting others within the community. This event is from 6-8 and all are welcome to come, if you don’t know who to bring come alone this is a great mixer event! This is an event hosted by Big Sky OUT as we work to provide queer safe spaces throughout the community.
Time
(Sunday) 6:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Location
Cowboy Coffee
25 Town Center Ave. Big Sky, MT 59716